Snickerdoodle Ice Cream

I’ve written here before about my youngest son’s undying love for the almighty Snickerdoodle.  While he loved the Snickerdoodle Muffins I made him, they did not stand a chance against this Snickerdoodle Ice Cream

Honestly, I think this is the best ice cream I have ever made.  The most amazing part; it tastes exactly like a Snickerdoodle.  Exactly.

When my picky eater tasted this, his eyes lit up in amazement.  “Mom, how did you do this?”  Music to my ears.  I got him.

Not only is this delicious, it happens to be about one of the easiest recipes to throw together.  There is no custard to make.  No cooling off period in the fridge and it sets up nice in the freezer.

Photographing ice cream is always a challenge.  I always freeze the dishes to keep the ice cream cold, freeze the ice cream scoop and work quickly, otherwise…it just melts.  No real surprises.  As I was dishing this ice cream out for its little paparazzi shoot, I left the scoop in the container and placed it back in the freezer (just in case I needed to scoop more later).  After I was done taking pictures I put everything away and retrieved the scoop from inside the ice cream box.  The scoop had lots of ice cream debris remaining on it and without thinking, I licked the scoop. 

The frozen, metal scoop. 

My bad.  Ouch. 

All I can say is, I won’t be doing that again anytime soon.  Ugh.

Enjoy this ice cream, I highly recommend it.

In a large bowl combine 1/2 cup granulated sugar, 1/2 cup packed light brown sugar, 1/2 teaspoon cinnamon and 1/8 teaspoon nutmeg.  Add 2 cups heavy whipping cream, 1-1/2 cups half and half and 1-1/2 teaspoons vanilla extract and mix until smooth; I used my hand-mixer.

Pour the cold mixture immediately into ice cream maker and freeze according to the manufacturer’s instructions.  Mine took about 20 minutes.

Scoop ice cream into a freezer safe-container.  Freeze.

Garnish with a Snickerdoodle cookie if you have some.  We always do.

Snickerdoodle Ice Cream
Adapted from Recipe Girl

1/2 cup granulated sugar
1/2 cup packed light brown sugar
1/2 teaspoon ground cinnamon
1/8 teaspoon ground nutmeg
2 cups heavy whipping cream
1-1/2 cups half and half cream
1-1/2 teaspoons vanilla extract

In a large bowl combine 1/2 cup granulated sugar, 1/2 cup packed light brown sugar, 1/2 teaspoon cinnamon and 1/8 teaspoon nutmeg.  Add 2 cups heavy whipping cream, 1-1/2 cups half and half and 1-1/2 teaspoons vanilla extract and mix until smooth; I used my hand-mixer.

Pour the cold mixture immediately into ice cream maker and freeze according to the manufacturer’s instructions.  Mine took about 20 minutes.

Scoop ice cream into a freezer safe-container.  Freeze.

One Year Ago:  A Classic Turned Fuzzy

Post a Comment

82 Comments

  1. This just might be the perfect recipe to have my granddaughters help me make. Hot weather and ice cream, snickerdoodle ice cream at that!

  2. deeba 2

    I’ve read & re read this a number of times. U serious? No EGGS? I love it Cathy! Your son has good taste, & his mother is fab! This is a great great recipe. Oh, and BTW, really sorry about your tongue…OUCH!!

  3. Wow, you’ve got me, too! The only thing better than snickerdoodles themselves would be snickerdoodle ice cream. If they sold that in shops, that would be the #1 flavor (well, if it were as good as yours anyway). I only have an old-fashioned (think labor intensive) ice cream maker, but this is a reason to run right out and get one. A late BD present to myself perhaps … sounds good to me!

    Thank you, Cathy! You are a rock star as always. :-)

    Shirley

  4. Wow, snickerdoodle ice cream sounds very neat and so good! I love this recipe!

  5. I made Snickerdoodle ice cream over the 4th and loved it. Wasn’t this no custard recipe however. I’ll have to try this one next. Can’t remember if I told you that I made the blueberry ice cream this weekend. WONDERFU, and I even messed up and used the wrong carton, milk instead of cream. Darnit. It’s still very good.

  6. Barbie with a T 6

    Now that makes me want to go out and buy an ice cream maker! It looks so refreshing. Another one of those “healthy” desserts. Well, it does contain milk. lol

  7. That looks unbelievably delicious. I adore snickerdoodles.

  8. Alta 8

    Wow, this looks amazing!

  9. Yum! Again I cannot wait. thanks.

  10. Yup! You got him with that one!
    Amazing!

    And I’m going to remember the frozen scoop wisdom as well!

  11. HoneyB 11

    just imagining this sandwiched between snickerdoodle cookies!

  12. Ginny 12

    yum! I love snickerdoodles… Unfortunately (or fortunately for my weight), I don’t have an ice cream maker… one day! :)

  13. I was flipping through Martha Stewart’s new cupcakes cookbook and saw a recipe for Snickerdoodle Cupcakes. I didn’t buy the cookbook, but I think I might go on Amazon and get it just so I can make that recipe.

  14. Ramona 14

    I going to desperately try and remember to pick up the ingredients tonight. My brother is going off shore for a month this weekend and I want to cook him a good meal. I think he would love this ice cream to top it off.

    Ramona

  15. Liz C. 15

    Believe it or not, I’ve never tasted a snickerdoodle. It sounds like something I wouldn’t be able to stop eating, so I must avoid it at all costs. However, I’m sure the Hooligans loved this…

  16. Oh my Lord I just died and went to ice cream heaven! And drat! We have all these blueberries and raspberries I have to use first before I can dig into this recipe. I don’t know if I can wait.

  17. Rindy R 18

    My kids LOVE snickerdoodles – I have never been closer to buying an ice cream maker then right now!!!

  18. Debby J 19

    Our oldest grandson LOVES snickerdoodles and I love making them for him. I’m going to have to surprise him with this ice cream. Just a tiny FYI – there’s a typo in your recipe. It currently says 1/8 tsp cinnamon instead of nutmeg. Thanks for a great recipe!

  19. grace 20

    this is simply unfair. actually, it’s probably best that this isn’t within arm’s reach because i would get FAT. ridiculously, irreconcilably fat.

  20. This looks delicious! Thanks for sharing!

  21. Lisa A. 22

    I’ve made the mistake of licking the frozen scoop before, and it is NOT fun. However, I love ice cream so much, I think I lose my mind for a second every time and just keep doing it!

  22. Fallon 24

    Oh yum! Now if only I had an ice cream maker!!

  23. Josie 26

    PSA: If your tongue is stuck to a frozen metal object, just pour water over it, and it releases without having to tear any taste buds off! (I am sure your son could have helped you… and it would have made a funny story for him later ;))

    That ice cream looks awesome!

  24. krysta 27

    i hate photographing ice cream too. but this one is now on my must make list because i love snickerdoodles.

  25. vanessa 28

    I have no idea what a snickerdoodle tastes like, but this looks GOOD.

  26. Bob 29


    Oh man, I’m going to put on so much weight.

  27. Rockin ice cream! No one’s ever made that one for us before, and it’s a nice way to start today.

  28. Mary 31

    This is a diet killer of a recipe. It looks incredibly good. Now, to test my will power.

  29. Marjie 32

    I can see that entering my freezer. Maybe today.

  30. imom 33

    The snickerdoodle fans at my house would love this ice cream! It sounds so easy to make too. Wow!

  31. One can never have too many excuses to make ice cream. Goodness :)

  32. Marlene 35

    This is similar to my go to ice cream recipe so I know it must be good.

    and the spoon…made me think of the little boy in The Christmas Story…and the pole.

  33. elra 36

    Wow, all the goodies is in this ice cream. Yum!

  34. Alisa 37

    Seriously…I’m pretty sure I love you. If that makes me odd, I don’t want to be even.

  35. Ooh I must try this one out, sounds so easy!

  36. Ouch! Sorry about your tongue! This reminded me of Christmas Story. :0)

    What a great flavor! Your recipe does look easier. I’ll have to try it!

  37. Sounds like something I would do… so excited to taste that I wouldn’t be thinking about the tongue thing (get well soon :) )

    Thanks for trying this out… I’m a Snickerdoodle FANATIC, and I’m glad you liked it too!!

  38. Dena G 41

    I have this in the ice cream freezer now!

  39. Lisa Sipple 42

    My kids are going to love you.

  40. I’m surprised that no thickening agent is required for this frozen treat. I just bookmarked the recipe. My little sis’-in-law is allergic to eggs. This recipe is perfect for her. Beautiful pic, as usual

  41. Kate 44

    Can I come and live at your house?

  42. Snickerdoodles are my weakness…

  43. BWAHAHA sorry couldn’t help it, I laughed out loud with the vision of your tongue stuck to that scoop. Hee hee… chuckle giggle snort.

  44. Steph 48

    The icecream looks delicious! At times like these, I wish I had an icecream maker.

  45. gp 49

    absolute yum.. perfect day here to indulge!

    gp

  46. pam 50

    Ice cream, easy, snickerdoodle. What else is there to say!

  47. Karine 51

    Wowowow I love your pics and this ice cream looks amazing!

  48. lo 52

    Oh, gosh. What could be better than frozen snickerdoodle?? As soon as I’m done working my way through Lebovitz, this is going on my list of things to make!! :) Heaven.

  49. annbb 53

    That looks delicious. And you have more energy that 14,000 energizer bunnies! Don’t know how you do all you do, but glad you do and that you share it with all us not so energizered folks.

  50. giz 54

    This is like combining the muffin and the ice cream together and having it all at one time – so hence half the calories. That works, doesn’t it??? Please say yes mom, puleeeeez

  51. Pam 55

    A boy after my own heart. Snickerdoodles are the best…I take that back. Snickerdoodle ice cream is the best! Can’t wait to make this one.

  52. Hilary 56

    Hi Cathy .. glad he can eat .. and I hope he enjoys himself .. and leaves some for the rest of the family.

    Hilary Melton-Butcher
    Positive Letters Inspirational Stories

  53. Kim 57

    I grew up eating snickerdoodles and adore them. They happen to be the state cookie of Connecticut. Somehow I missed your snickerdoodle muffins? Will give those a try and this yummy looking icecream. Thanks for the tongue warning, as that is something I would do.

  54. Suzette 58

    Oh, my! My guy loves my snickerdoodles. Loves ‘em. And he loves my homemade ice cream. I think you’ve given me the tools to totally bushwhack him. He doesn’t stand a chance!

  55. Biz 59

    Holy cow – that looks amazing!!

    I need an icecream maker now!

  56. You’ve just brought back a terrible memory. I got my tongue stuck to a creamsicle when I was a child. Oh,,the pain. This ice cream looks heavenly. Love the flavors.

  57. This sounds so good! Cinnamon in ice cream always reminds me of Mexican fried ice cream. Which I love!

  58. What a great creation – I love the cookies so I am sure the ice cream will put me over the top!! Excited to try this one!

  59. I hope your tongue has survived the slaughter!

    This ice cream would be WONDERFUL with apple pie.

  60. Lisa 64

    I am soooo in a Snickerdoodle mood and bummed that I don’t have an ice cream freezer. Your pictures are quite tempting!

  61. You might be having me make ice cream yet! This looks amazing!

  62. I’ve never actually had a snickerdoodle but this sounds amazing with cinnamon and nutmeg!

  63. Misty 67

    Wonderful Cathy…I have been wanting something simple & this looks easy & YUMMY! Thanks!

  64. dawn 68

    oh dear, this and some chunks of snickerdoodle muffins or cookies are a match made in heaven–seriously.
    wow!

  65. Donna 69

    This is the reason I am on the hunt for an ice cream maker.. tomorrow, screw my houseguests, they can do without me for a while. I want one so I can make this!

  66. I wish I had an ice cream maker!

    I actually had one that I got for my wedding 14 years ago, and after moving it several times without ever opening it, I sold it at a yard sale…now I want it back!

  67. KAYOLA 72

    We make homemade ice cream quite often…so we will try this…it looks de-lish!!! LOVE SNICKERDOODLES!!!!!!

  68. peabody 73

    Well I do love all things Snickerdoodle. This ice cream sounds wonderful!

  69. We haven’t even tasted this incredible-looking concoction, but we’re pretty sure you’ve got us too! Honestly, who wouldn’t love Snickerdoodle Ice Cream?

  70. Alisha 75

    I think that would make a great milkshake, too.

  71. megan 76

    OMG! This looks heavenly! Do I dare? Should I dare?, Would I dare? LOL

  72. Taylee 77

    Oh my YUM! No seriously I need some of that! My mouth began to salivate the moment I read snickerdoodle. MMMM

  73. livlaugheat 78

    thanks for posting this! i just made it (one of the easiest ice cream recipes ever) and it tastes amazing. i can’t wait for it to cure in the freezer so i can dig in!

  74. Just had to report back that I made this recipe last night using coconut milk instead of dairy for our support group (we have a lot of dairy free folks) and everyone agreed it was heavenly. What a wonderful way to break in my new ice cream maker! Thanks, Cathy!

    Shirley

  75. Commercial Litigation and IP Law International Business Attorneys

  76. justine 81

    Just made this with a few minor changes (a bit less sugar and a bit more vanilla) and it is great! Bringing it to an autumn pot luck tonight, to be served in baked apple “bowls.” Thanks!

    PS. Going to share on my Twitter feed now :-)

  77. OMG! My Hubby loves anything snickerdoodle! He will flip over these :) Yay! Thanks, Cathy!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>