Gnocchi-Bacon Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Gnocchi Bacon Grilled Cheese
Happy National Grilled Cheese Day!! My contribution to the madness of this lovely designated day is the Gnocchi-Bacon Grilled Cheese Sandwich. It's kind of over-the-top don't you think? A sort of carb-lover's dream. I guess that's why it fits into my life so perfectly. 

I had never thought of putting pasta into a sandwich before...until now. I mean, why not a lasagna sandwich too? Or a rigatoni hoagie?? I'm all about it. I'm calling it a new trend.

This particular sandwich has everything I love; cheese, bacon, gnocchi (pasta + potato)'s truly perfection.'s also half a sandwich filling. But it would be great with all kinds of soup.

Gnocchi Bacon Grilled Cheese cheese
I used two of my favorite cheeses, Gruyere and Pecorino-Romano. The Gruyere is an extraordinarily complex-melty cheese and Pecorino Romano is salty. I also use these two cheeses in my Gnocchi Man n' Cheese along with some Fontina. It's just the perfect combo.

Gnocchi Bacon Grilled Cheese bread
Depending on what type of bread you use for your sandwich will determine how you build it. I used a bolillo roll. I sliced it in half and dug out some of the bread on the bottom and top. This made it easier to pile the gnocchi in without the bread sitting too high.

Gnocchi Bacon Grilled Cheese buttered pan
After I boiled my gnocchi, I took them directly from the water and put them into a hot pan full of butter. I sauteed them until they were somewhat browned and crispy.

Gnocchi Bacon Grilled Cheese sandwich building
I toasted my roll before I built my sandwich in order to get a crispy inside. I buttered the inside too.

Gnocchi Bacon Grilled Cheese frying in the pan
Now, obviously with a roll like this (not flat on both sides) I knew I would not be able to flip the sandwich over in the pan. So, I placed the sandwich in a skillet of hot butter and while it cooked, I brushed butter from the pan around the sides and over the top to make sure everything was melty and warm. It worked great.Gnocchi Bacon Grilled Cheese Sandwich
My husband kind of fell off his chair when I brought this to him for lunch. Ha-ha. There wasn't any left.

Print Recipe

Gnocchi-Bacon Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Recipe from: Created by Cathy Pollak for | Serves: Serves 4


  • 8 slices bacon, cooked
  • 4 crusty rolls, sliced lengthwise, toasted and insides buttered
  • 1/2 cup butter, divided
  • 1 pound gnocchi, dry
  • 1 cup shredded Gruyere cheese
  • 1 cup Pecorino-Romano cheese


  • Cook bacon over medium heat until crispy. Set aside.
  • Slice rolls lengthwise and toast in toaster oven or oven until slightly brown, butter the insides.
  • Cook gnocchi according to package directions. When they are done place them directly into a hot, nonstick skillet with a couple Tablespoons of butter. Brown the gnocchi until crispy. Keep warm.
  • Build each sandwich by scooping out some of the bread (see picture) of the top and bottom of the roll. Layer each sandwich starting with Pecorino-Romano cheese, browned gnocchi, 2 slices of bacon, more gnocchi and Gruyere cheese and top half of bread. Place each sandwich into nonstick skillet with more butter. If you cannot flip the sandwich, just use a kitchen brush to brush on butter from the pan to the top and sides of bread.
  • Slice in half to serve.

 Four Year's Ago: It's All Spring to Me

Post a Comment

13 Comments and 1 Reply

  1. Kristin 1

    I’m speechless!! So over the top, but oh so right! I’m getting on a plane today to come to your house for one of these. Ha ha. I think I’d have to walk back to Florida to burn off all the wonderful calories though. :-)

  2. Megan 2

    How do you always come up with things that shouldn’t be real, but then when you see/read them, you wonder how the world never came up with such masterpieces before?!!??!! aka this looks so phenomenal.

  3. Angelica 3

    Marry me. This is genius!! ;)

  4. Jeremy Norton 4

    This recipe is absolutely worth the try. I am so in love with gnocchi and so with sandwiches.

  5. Pam 5

    Oh Cathy. You sure know how to make a girl drool. They look AMAZING!

  6. ohmygosh! totally salivating here.

  7. Holy carb, but how great that probably tasted. I like potatoes in sandwiches and this just takes it one step further.

  8. Shaina 8

    I have a freezer full of homemade gnocchi. Um..I now have an idea on how to rid myself of that problem.

  9. Anna 9

    Your Gnocchi Mac n Cheese is one of my favorite dishes, so I MUST try this one as well!

  10. Holy cow, this is genius. Wish I had one for breakfast!

  11. Ralph 11

    Deliciously evil!

    I substituted fried mushrooms and asparagus for the bacon – being afflicted by vegetarianism – but it was super. I do feel inclined to sink into a carb-induced coma though. Mmmm – lunch-time nap!

  12. Rhonda 12

    Is this potato gnocchi or ricotta gnocchi? I would love to make this :)

  13. Jenny 14

    I made this tonight for my boyfriend. HUGE hit. Served it with some homemade tomato soup, perfect for a chilly night! Thank you!


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 Notify me of followup comments via e-mail.

You can click here to Subscribe without commenting