Greek Yogurt-Apple Pie Milkshakes

 Greek Yogurt Apple Pie Milkshake with a shake of cinnamon
I have always subscribed to the idea that it’s important to repurpose leftovers. I make leftover pot roast into pot roast tacos and leftover steak gets put into scrambled eggs. It keeps things interesting and allows me to stretch another meal out my previous hard work.

Now, a while back I posted a recipe for my Epic Apple Pie-Buttermilk Shake. And epic is a great way to describe that recipe. It’s sweet and tangy and tastes exactly like apple pie. What’s different about this recipe here and the one previously written is how you arrive at the finished product. It’s completely different. Completely.

Last week I had a dinner party and our friends brought over a farm stand apple pie. It was delicious. I am still trying to figure out the crust, it was perfect. Not flaky (which is what I thought I wanted in a pie) but this was crumby in texture. I want to know how to make that crust, it was really perfect and authentic tasting.

Greek Yogurt Apple Pie Milkshake leftover pie
Anyway, after the party this is what was left of the apple pie, a little more than one piece. Ten- ounces to be exact. 

While I could have perfectly enjoyed this piece of pie I decided to make a milkshake out of it. As usual a bunch of teenage boys were over and a sweet treat is always requested. I didn’t have enough pie to feed all of them so I decided to blend this up with some Greek yogurt, milk and ice.

Seriously it was so delicious and it tasted exactly like apple pie. And the kids unknowingly got a bunch of protein from the yogurt. Perfect!

Print Recipe

Greek Yogurt-Apple Pie Milkshake

Recipe from: Created by Cathy Pollak for | Serves: Makes 3 cups


  • 10 ounces leftover apple pie
  • 1 cup vanilla Greek yogurt (such as Chobani)
  • 1 cup whole milk
  • 1 cup ice
  • ground cinnamon, optional


  • Add all ingredients except cinnamon to a blender. Blend until smooth and pour into glasses. Sprinkle with a dash of cinnamon if you choose. Serve immediately.

Greek Yogurt Apple Pie Milkshake
I resisted every urge I had to plop whipped cream on the top of this…maybe next time.

One Year Ago: Blogging Has Its Perks
Two Years Ago: Grilled Broccoli and Lemons
Three Years Ago: Harry Potter’s Butterbeer
Five Years Ago: Fancy Schmancy Chocolate Chip Cookies

Post a Comment


  1. Katie 1

    This sounds divine! I love the idea of blending up the piece of leftover apple pie!

  2. Whoa! Apple pie in a milkshake? That is genius! I love greek yogurt and I mean, this has got to be the perfect transition drink from summer to fall. YUM!

  3. This is so genius! Bookmarking it for all the holiday leftover pie this year. Thanks for sharing!

  4. How genius is this! Yay for fall flavors!

  5. What a fantastic idea! Not enough pie for everyone to enjoy but blended up it goes the distance. Love it!

    Pie crust seem so tricky. If you learn the secret of that crumbly crust please share!

  6. You have just totally reminded me of something. Back when we lived in Toronto one of my favorite ice cream places made a pumpkin pie ice cream where they actually took whole pies and churned them into something beyond amazing. I’m thinking apple pie would work too. Or I could expend less effort and make this delicious milkshake idea you’ve got here. I am inspired!

  7. I would adore a milkshake from apple pie! What a great idea!

  8. A Apple Pie Milkshake sounds like it would be the most delicious treat, possibly ever! I need to try this! :)

  9. Oh my gosh, how fun is this?!

  10. Such a great idea! I love that you used leftover pie!

  11. Sues 11

    You put leftover apple pie into a milkshake??? You are my HERO!!!

  12. These are just so perfect for Fall! Can’t wait to slurp one down.

  13. Mmm what a fabulous recipe! Love this!

  14. Ohmahgosh! Who knew the best way to enjoy a big ol’ slice of leftover apple pie? We do, now! Thanks for sharing, Cathy!

  15. Such a perfect combo!

  16. I love that you used yogurt here! This looks incredible.

  17. Get out!! Apple pie IN the shake?!? That is just genius. Yum!

  18. Great way to stretch one piece of pie! Nothing goes to waste in my house either, learned that from my momma :)

  19. OMG how awesome that there is actual apple pie in this!!!!! Saving this recipe! Brilliant :)

  20. I am such a believer in repurposing things too. I love this idea with the apple pie! Sounds delicious!

  21. I could literally drink one of these everyday! What a great idea!

  22. Greek yogurt milkshake is an amazingly delicious way to eat the already delicious Greek yogurt. And you also sneaked in some apple pie in there??? Perfecto!

  23. creamylicious, healthful,filling and refreshing sip,this just can’t get better :-)

  24. What an awesome way to use left over pie!

  25. Des 25

    Yum! Fall is in the air but it is still warm Apple Pie Milkshakes sound perfect!

  26. Wow amazing combination! Great idea!


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 Notify me of followup comments via e-mail.

You can click here to Subscribe without commenting