The Best Classic Popovers with Tips and Tricks

 Classic Popovers with Tips and Tricks for Making the Best
I am obsessed with popovers at the moment. After getting my new popover pans last week I have made many different versions. I’ve been testing different temperatures and methods to get them just right.

Honestly they are so easy to put together and come out perfect when you adhere to a few simple rules. 

Popovers are the American version of Yorkshire Pudding and are named for their ability to “pop over” the tins in which they are baked. Popovers are light and airy and can be served with almost any meal. 

They are perfect with all kinds of sweet or savory toppings or enjoyed just with butter. I love them with pot roast, using the popover to dip in the gravy. Or have them with tea with some jam…it’s a classic way to serve them.

Classic Popovers  Chicago Metallic Pan
These are the popover pans I use and they are fairly inexpensive. Each set makes six popovers. 

Classic Popovers  2 Chicago Metallic Pans
However, I highly suggest having 2 sets of popover pans on hand. Popovers are very light and airy and most people will have more than one to enjoy with their meal. Since they must be served immediately you would not want to wait for another set to be baked and served.

Classic Popovers with Tips and Tricks
The popovers come out of the pan easily and are served hot at the table. Be careful of the steam.

Tips and Tricks for the Best Classic Popovers

  • Place popover pans on an 11 x 17 baking tray and place in the oven while you are preheating. The popover pan must be hot for best results.
  • Warm milk before to roughly 125 degrees before mixing with the eggs and flour. The warmer batter helps get the popovers cooking right away. This makes for a larger and taller popover.
  • Spray popover pans vigorously with cooking spray right before pouring batter into the cups.
  • Mix batter only until lumps are gone, do not overmix.
  • Start with a higher oven temperature and turn down after fifteen minutes.
  • Never open the oven during the baking process.
  • Serve immediately.

Print Recipe

The Best Classic Popovers with Tips and Tricks

Recipe from: Created by Cathy Pollak for NoblePig.com | Serves: Makes 12 popovers

Ingredients

  • 2 cups whole milk
  • 4 large eggs
  • 1-1/2 teaspoons salt
  • 2 cups all-purpose flour

Directions

  • Preheat oven to 450 degrees. Place popover pans on an 11 x 17 baking sheet and put in the bottom third of the oven during the preheat process.
  • Warm or scald milk on the stove over medium heat until hot, about 125 degrees, do not boil. Remove from heat.
  • In a large bowl, whisk eggs and salt until smooth. Slowly whisk in warm milk, about a half a cup at a time. Add flour and mix gently, just until lumps are gone.
  • Remove popover pans from the oven and spray vigorously with cooking spray. Pour batter into a a large pitcher so it is easier to pour and fill each cup a little less than half full. Return to the oven immediately.
  • Bake popovers for 15 minutes at 450 degrees. Turn down oven to 350 degrees and bake for 10 minutes more. Remove popovers from the pan and serve immediately.
Classic Popovers
If you have never tried making these, you will be pleasantly surprised how easy they are to put together. It’s a fun and impressive dish.

One Year Ago: Ranch Hand Beans
Five Years Ago: Baked Ham with Rum and Coke Glaze

Post a Comment

16 Comments and 8 Replies

  1. You make me want to bake popovers! I need a mini pan that only makes 6–how perfect!

  2. I love the classic recipes and this is one of the absolute best! I’ll take a popover (or two) any time of day. And my favorite way to have them is with pot roast as well.

  3. This is great, Kathy. My popovers are usually hit and miss, but I’ve never made them with scalded milk. Maybe that is just the thing I need to make mine foolproof.

    Thank you!!

  4. These look absolutely fabulous! I would love to hear what other kinds of popover flavor combos you have made. I’ve always been a little intimidated to make these but you make it seem easy :)

  5. My MIL gave me a cast iron popover pan when we got married. It needs regular seasoning when using it. My family thinks I’m the best EVER when I make popovers. I may make some tonight! Thanks for the tips…I never spray mine (just re-seasoning that cast iron) but may give that a try. Thanks, Cathy!

  6. Your popovers are so perfect! I have yet to make them because those pans aren’t available here in Europe. I do hope to give them a try sometime. Thanks for sharing!

  7. Annie Wyatt 11

    I’m in Australia so might have to try ebay for tins… but I so want to try these.
    I love your site. Thank You so much for your unique recipes. I sometimes feel like an
    honorary Yank! :)

    • Alyson 12

      I have great luck with regular muffin pans. I do add about 2 tab. melted butter to the batter, spray the pans with nonstick and add a dab of margarine (higher smoking point) or better yet bacon drippings (just a little pinch). Heat the pans until smoking then add batter almost to the top. I found it was not necessary to scald the milk, just make sure it was a little warm. (I heat in the microwave and whisk in cold eggs so that it is warm not hot) After many years of lead sinkers as long as the batter is warm they pop up as fluffy as can be, even little ones in mini muffin pans pop well! Also try add ing 3/4 tsp dry mustard and a couple of cubes of Gruyere for Cheesy Popovers. I also grate extra Gruyere just out of the oven!

  8. jeri 13

    Beautiful popovers. Your never-open-the -oven-door tip is the most important thing. I just use regular cupcake tins and I’ve never heated my milk, and they’ve always turned out great. Except the one time I peeked…PLOPovers. I know it’s hard, but no peeking.

  9. Doug Prather 14

    Good thing to do with leftovers in the morning:
    1. Make more popovers ’cause there’s no such thing as leftover popovers.
    2. Gently pull the fresh popovers open a bit and slip in a big spoon of a your favorite egg, cheese, sausage/ bacon scramble.
    3. Serve. Eat. Repeat.

    Easy breakfast for a group.

  10. Debbie H. 17

    Popovers look beautiful. Would you mind answering a couple of questions? You said to preheat popover tins on a baking sheet … Do they remain on baking sheet when Returned to oven for baking? Preheat in bottom third of oven … Bake in bottom third of oven? Thanks so much!

  11. I am so excited to bake my own version of popover. I just received a set of pan last week.

  12. Leslie Gaunt 20

    Yum! Made these last night, they are amazing. I found it nearly impossible to resist having “just popovers” for my dinner! I had been longing for a popover pan, and finally found one at Cost Plus World Market in the clearance section for $4.50!!! I got mine yesterday, who knows if they are at other locations!

  13. PG 21

    Great tips! I don’t think I’ve ever actually seen a popover pan. I always just use muffin tins. But, I am going to try this recipe because my recipe includes putting oil in the tin and then heating before adding the mixture. More often than not, I end up setting off the smoke alarm. Then, the popovers stick to the pan anyway.

    So true about serving immediately. A part of me loses it when people are late for a dinner than includes popovers.

    Happy Passover to you too!

  14. Tracy Dane 22

    I’m English, living in France, and I love Yorkshire Puddings. Mum always used to use the fat produced by the Sunday roast ( usually beef) to cook the Yorkies. Another favourite is Toad-in-the-hole. The same batter, cooked in a large tin with sausages then served with onion gravy. A hearty family meal.

  15. My family loves popovers and somehow mine never turn out as nice as yours. Thanks for the tips, especially about warming the milk.

    I like Doug’s idea about stuffing them with cheesy eggs. The savory ones sound more appealing to me than what my family does, which is sweet with a pat of butter, a dusting of powder sugar, and a squeeze of lemon.
    San

  16. Jamie 24

    Wowee what stunning, perfect popovers! Thanks for the tips – I used to make popovers 30 years ago just out of college and they were great. Last time I tried to make them in France they were a miserable failure and I so want to make them again. And have them come out like yours! And now a popover pan (or 2) is on my wish list!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>